All of my reasons: S tier: Basketball: I thought she was a really cool contestant and I liked her arc with Golf Ball. Eraser: He got out super unfairly and I want to see more of his arcs Foldy: She's gotten way better than before, she is now one of my favorite characters! I never thought I would say that. Fries: He's just awesome. Lightning: He tried his best and didn't deserve the early elimination. Liy: She got out so unfairly. I blame the writers Puffball: Her friendship can really grow with Golf Ball, and she got out way early in both BFDIA and TPOT (and BFB if that counts) Pin: She got out because she was still in BFDIA, which I find so unfair Remote: She's awesome Snowball: He really grew on me and I really wish he hadn't gotten out. A tier: Bomby: He is really funny in BFDIA and he really needed more in TPOT. Cake: He grew on me a lot as well and I really like him. Cloudy: Rewatching BFB really made me like Cloudy better. Pie: She is just so funny Pillow: A lot would disagree but I just like her personality RF: She is one of the best robots in the show Tree: He didn't deserve to be eliminated tbh Winner: I was just mad he got out over Book, so I'd be happy if he rejoined C tier: Barf Bag: I don't see how she can grow since her old friend Spongy is gone, but maybe she can grow her friendship with Donut Gaty: Well I think her arc is finished and I don't think I'd be happy for her return, but maybe it'll make Two happy though Nickel: Honestly, Nickel is better in BFDIA. In TPOT he is just saying stuff like, "wowie zowie dum dum bozo" Saw: 8 YF: I don't see what he can add to the story tbh D tier: Bell: what can she do Bottle: She just shatters every now and then Clock: He has nothing else to do Coiny: No hate toward Coiny, but what has he done in TPOT? He is overrated in TPOT tbh. BFDIA was his season so... Naily: Who remembers her though? Needle: She's a runner up, so I don't think she needs to rejoin Rocky: All he's done in TPOT was stand there and barf. Teardrop: She made it 3rd place in BFB. TV: Wait, what has he done in TPOT as a contestant F tier: Eggy: NO Ice Cube: Am I too harsh on her? I still can't forgive her for removing Pin's face. Ruby is an exception because Ruby is the best. Finally I'm done! I hope I didn't miss anyone.
